
False and Inaccurate Information: Why?
Unfortunately, we live in a world where misinformation, disinformation, and scams are all over the place. There are various reasons why someone would want to participate in facilitating these behaviors. Firstly, misinformation is spread accidentally and happens when people don’t do their own research or fact-check. Disinformation is purposeful and can happen for a number of reasons, including by those trying to achieve their own personal agenda. Lastly, scams may be done for money, forced labor, and extortion purposes.
Reality and AI
AI is an extremely important thing to talk about, especially considering it will be a huge part of our lives. The most interesting thing about how AI is exploding right now is the parallels it shares with the computer boom around the 1980s. In relation to those who have already began to adapt to AI, CMIT Solutions says “they’re freeing up their human teams to focus on the high-value, creative, relationship-driven work that machines can’t touch.” While this might mean that we must verify all the information we see, perhaps that is better for improving critical thinking.
Nebula One
OpenAI Opened
This AI model provided two sources from Purdue University which is a very reputable website with helpful information and plenty of resources. Along with this, there is another repeat source that wants you to sign up for their services. These sources are more on the trustworthy side because they include scholarly and well known websites.
Tokens: 43,253
Conversation Title: Guidance on creative writing process and resources
Agent: ONEchat
[09/08/2026] (glar5):
Hello! I’m really interested in writing a story, something I have never fully been able to get into. I’m planning for a creative short story under 5k words. I already have the idea built in my head so don’t provide anything like details or characters. What I would like to know is how the creative writing process works. Please provide sources that will help me to get started.
Response:
A creative writing process is usually a cycle rather than a strict formula: prepare, draft, revise, edit, and—if desired—share. Different writers plan extensively, discover the story while drafting, or combine both approaches.[doc1][doc2]
1. Prepare without overplanning
Since your idea is already developed, begin by writing a brief statement of what the story is fundamentally exploring. This is not a synopsis; it is a private guide for keeping the story focused.
For a short story under 5,000 words, it helps to limit the piece to:
- One central line of action
- One main conflict
- A small number of important events
- A consistent point of view
- A focused emotional or thematic effect
Short stories generally rely on compression, so plot, character, conflict, setting, and theme need to work together rather than operate as separate subplots.[doc1][doc2]
2. Choose how much to plan
You do not need a detailed outline. You can either:
- Outline first: decide the major turns before drafting.
- Discovery-write: begin writing and discover the story through the process.
- Use a hybrid approach: identify only the opening situation, major turning point, climax, and ending.
The best method is the one that helps you continue writing without making the process feel mechanical.[doc2]
3. Draft for completion, not quality
The first draft is primarily an act of discovery. Avoid trying to perfect every sentence while writing; leave placeholders, skip difficult passages temporarily, or write scenes out of order if necessary.[doc2]
A useful first-draft goal is simply to reach the end. You may discover that the story’s structure, emphasis, or ending changes as you write. That is normal: drafting reveals possibilities that planning cannot always predict.[doc2]
4. Revise the story as a whole
Revision is more than correcting grammar. Start by asking whether the complete draft creates the effect you intended.
Read for:
- Whether the story begins at the most effective moment
- Whether each event contributes to the central movement
- Whether cause and effect are clear
- Whether tension develops rather than remaining flat
- Whether the ending feels earned
- Whether anything can be removed without weakening the story
Purdue describes plot as the meaningful arrangement of actions and emphasizes the connection between character decisions, conflict, and consequences.[doc1] Reedsy recommends examining narrative threads, removing unnecessary material, and checking that the ending is neither unexplained nor confusing.[doc2]
5. Revise in layers
Do not try to solve every problem at once. A practical sequence is:
- Structure: Is the story coherent and appropriately focused?
- Scene or paragraph function: Does each section contribute something?
- Clarity and pacing: Is the reader receiving information at the right time?
- Voice and style: Does the language create the intended tone?
- Sentence editing: Can the prose be more precise or economical?
- Proofreading: Correct spelling, grammar, punctuation, and formatting last.
Sentence-level polishing is most efficient after structural decisions are settled, because otherwise you may spend time refining material that will later be cut.[doc2][doc3]
6. Take distance and seek feedback
After finishing a draft, step away from it before revising. Time makes it easier to notice what is actually on the page rather than what you remember intending to write.[doc2]
When you share the story, ask readers specific questions instead of simply asking whether they liked it. For example: “Where did your attention dip?” or “What did you think the story was ultimately about?” Reader responses can show you what the draft communicates independently of your intentions.[doc2]
7. Polish and decide whether to share it
Read the story aloud to catch awkward phrasing, repetitive rhythms, and unnatural dialogue.[doc4] Then proofread the final version and, if you plan to submit it, check each publication’s guidelines before sending it.[doc2]
A simple starting routine would be:
- Write a one-paragraph private description of the story’s purpose.
- Make a short list of its major movements.
- Draft without stopping to perfect it.
- Leave it alone for several days.
- Revise for structure and focus.
- Revise for language.
- Read it aloud and proofread it.
- Ask one or two trusted readers for focused feedback.
Sources to get started
- Purdue OWL: Fiction Basics — reliable guidance on plot, character, conflict, and how fiction creates meaning.[doc1]
- Reedsy: How to Write a Short Story — a practical guide covering conception, drafting, editing, feedback, and submission.[doc2]
- Reedsy: How to Craft a Killer Short Story — a free, ten-part course focused specifically on short-story writing and publication.[doc5]
- Purdue OWL: Fiction Writing Exercises — optional exercises for practicing concrete detail, rhythm, description, and narrative technique.[doc6]
- StorySloth: Short Story Guide — a beginner-friendly checklist for drafting, revising, reading aloud, and getting feedback.[doc4]
The most important thing is to separate creating from judging: let the draft exist first, then evaluate and reshape it afterward.[doc2]
Anthropic Analyzed
What stood out about this AI model is that it provided a concise but extremely helpful answer, allowing the user to jump into the writing process. A couple of the sources were clearly primarily advertising services, such as Grammarly. One of the websites was outdated from 2002 and extremely hard to read through due to lack of accessibility. Another source unfortunately appeared to use AI for its graphics as twice it says “outuiling” rather than “outlining.” Overall, this model had hit or miss trustworthiness with some of the sources having really helpful specific information and others were a pain to navigate with general, unhelpful advice.
Tokens: 55,228
Conversation Title: Guidance on creative writing process and resources
Agent: ONEchat
[09/09/2026] (glar5):
Hello! I’m really interested in writing a story, something I have never fully been able to get into. I’m planning for a creative short story under 5k words. I already have the idea built in my head so don’t provide anything like details or characters. What I would like to know is how the creative writing process works. Please provide sources that will help me to get started.
Response:
Great! Here are reliable sources to guide you through the creative writing process for your short story:
Core Process Stages
The creative writing process typically consists of five stages[doc1][doc2][doc3]:
- Prewriting/Brainstorming – Generate ideas, ask questions, and gather material[doc1]. You don’t need this since you already have your idea built, but it establishes the foundation[doc2].
- Outlining – Organize your ideas into structure[doc2]. Some writers skip this (pantsers), while others find even a light outline helpful: beginning, inciting incident, midpoint shift, climax, and resolution[doc1].
- Drafting – Write your first version focusing on momentum, not perfection[doc1]. Write fast, fix later[doc1]. This is where you get messy and incomplete work onto the page[doc2].
- Revision – Improve content, structure, clarity, and flow. Revise in layers: start with big-picture issues (argument, structure) before touching sentences[doc1][doc2].
- Editing/Proofreading – Fix grammar, punctuation, and formatting. Do this last, not first[doc1][doc2].
Key Insight for Short Stories
The process differs slightly for short stories. You’ll want to start close to the climax and maintain tight focus on a single conflict[doc4][doc5]. Keep exposition minimal and avoid subplots[doc4].
Recommended Reading
Study short story masters—particularly Chekhov, Raymond Carver, Hemingway, Alice Munro, and Tobias Wolff[doc5]. Reading established short stories will teach you more about the craft than any single guide[doc5].
Recommended Sources to Explore
- The US Writers Guide[doc1] – Practical 8-stage workflow with emphasis on layered revision
- Writing Forward[doc6] – Flexible, adaptive processes for different projects
- Methodology Hub[doc2] – Detailed breakdown of all five stages with practical applications
- Grammarly’s Writing Process Guide[doc3] – Clear, accessible overview of each stage
- Writers.com Short Story Checklist[doc4] – Specific guidance for short story structure, characters, and submission
- Jerz’s Literacy Weblog[doc5] – 10 practical hacks covering first paragraphs, character development, dialogue, and conflict
You’re well-positioned since you already have your idea. Focus your effort on drafting first, then revision.
Mistrial Mystery
This model used the least trustworthy sources because while it provided the most sources, 8 of them had page not found errors. Another source was purely a quote that was irrelevant to the prompt. One source was advertising an AI writing agent. Overall, there is only one source that has in-depth, helpful information. The trustworthiness of these sources is pretty low given the significant portion of invalid pages.
Tokens: 4,114
Conversation Title: Hello! I’m really interested in writing a story, s
Agent: ONEchat
[09/09/2026] (glar5):
Hello! I’m really interested in writing a story, something I have never fully been able to get into. I’m planning for a creative short story under 5k words. I already have the idea built in my head so don’t provide anything like details or characters. What I would like to know is how the creative writing process works. Please provide sources that will help me to get started.
Response:
I’m sorry, the AI model is not responding. Please try your query again.
[09/09/2026] (glar5):
Hello! I’m really interested in writing a story, something I have never fully been able to get into. I’m planning for a creative short story under 5k words. I already have the idea built in my head so don’t provide anything like details or characters. What I would like to know is how the creative writing process works. Please provide sources that will help me to get started.
Response:
Here’s a clear, actionable breakdown of the creative writing process for a short story, along with authoritative sources to guide you. I’ve focused on the stages most relevant to your goal (under 5K words) and included practical tips to keep you moving forward.
1. Pre-Writing: Planning Without Over-Planning
Since you already have an idea, this stage is about clarifying and organizing it without getting stuck in endless outlines.
Key Steps:
- Core Idea Refinement
- Write a one-sentence summary of your story (e.g., “A reclusive clockmaker discovers his creations are counting down to his own death”).
- Ask: What’s the emotional core? (e.g., grief, fear, love) and What’s the central conflict?
- Character Sketches
- Jot down 3-5 key traits for your protagonist and antagonist (if any). Focus on:
- Desire: What do they want?
- Obstacle: What’s stopping them?
- Flaw: What’s their weakness?
- Tip: For short stories, limit characters to 3-4 max to avoid clutter.
- Jot down 3-5 key traits for your protagonist and antagonist (if any). Focus on:
- Structure Touchpoints
- Use a simple framework to map the story’s arc. For short stories, try:
- Freytag’s Pyramid: Exposition → Rising Action → Climax → Falling Action → Resolution.
- The “5 Key Scenes” Method:
- Opening (introduce character/setting).
- Inciting Incident (disrupts the status quo).
- Midpoint (character commits to action).
- Crisis (all seems lost).
- Resolution (change or revelation).
- Use a simple framework to map the story’s arc. For short stories, try:
- Setting Notes
- Describe the time, place, and mood in 3-5 sentences. Ask: How does the setting create tension or reflect the theme?
Sources for Pre-Writing:
- Book: Writing Fiction: A Guide to Narrative Craft by Janet Burroway (Chapter 2: “The Writing Process”).
- Article: “How to Write a Short Story: 10 Steps” by Reedsy Blog.
- Read Here (Focus on the “Planning” section).
- Tool: One-Page Outline Template from Save the Cat! Writes a Novel (adapted for short stories).
- Free Template (Ignore the “beat sheet” if it feels too rigid).
2. Drafting: Writing Freely
The goal here is momentum, not perfection. Short stories thrive on efficiency—every word should serve the core idea.
Key Steps:
- Set a Word Count Target
- Aim for 1,000–3,000 words for your first draft. You can expand or trim later.
- Write Out of Order
- Stuck on the opening? Start with the climax or a scene you’re excited about. Fill in the gaps later.
- Silence Your Inner Editor
- Use timed sprints (e.g., 25 minutes of writing, 5-minute break) to stay focused.
- Tip: If you delete nothing in the first draft, you’re doing it right.
- Dialogue as a Driver
- Short stories often rely on subtext (what’s not said). Write dialogue that reveals conflict or hidden emotions.
Sources for Drafting:
- Book: Bird by Bird by Anne Lamott (Chapter: “Shitty First Drafts”).
- Article: “The Secret to Writing a Great Short Story” by The Write Practice.
- Read Here (Focus on “Write Fast” and “Start in the Middle”).
- Podcast: Writing Excuses (Episode: “Writing Short Stories”).
- Listen Here (15-minute episode with actionable tips).
3. Revising: Shaping the Story
This is where you refine the draft into a polished piece. For short stories, revision is about precision.
Key Steps:
- Let It Rest
- Step away for at least 24 hours before revising. Fresh eyes catch more.
- Big-Picture Edits (Macro)
- Plot: Does every scene advance the story? Cut or merge scenes that don’t.
- Character: Are their motivations clear? Do their actions feel consistent?
- Pacing: Is the climax too rushed? Is the ending satisfying?
- Tip: Read the story aloud to spot awkward phrasing or pacing issues.
- Line Edits (Micro)
- Trim redundancies: Remove filler words (e.g., “just,” “that,” “very”).
- Show, Don’t Tell: Replace abstract emotions with concrete details (e.g., “She was nervous” → “She chewed her thumbnail raw”).
- Dialogue Tags: Use “said” or action beats (e.g., “He slammed the door. ‘You’re late.'”).
- Feedback
- Share with 1-2 trusted readers (not family/friends). Ask:
- What confused you?
- What felt emotionally flat?
- What did you love? (Keep these parts!)
- Share with 1-2 trusted readers (not family/friends). Ask:
Sources for Revising:
- Book: On Writing Well by William Zinsser (Part III: “Forms”).
- Article: “How to Edit Your Short Story” by The Creative Penn.
- Checklist: Short Story Editing Checklist by Now Novel.
4. Polishing: Final Touches
- Title: Brainstorm 10+ options. A great title hints at the theme or conflict (e.g., “The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson).
- Opening Line: Rewrite it last. It should hook the reader and set the tone.
- Formatting: Use standard manuscript format (double-spaced, 12pt font, 1-inch margins) if submitting to journals.
- Proofreading: Use tools like Grammarly or Hemingway Editor to catch errors.
Sources for Polishing:
- Article: “How to Write a Killer Opening Line” by Writer’s Digest.
- Tool: Hemingway Editor (for clarity and conciseness).
5. Sharing Your Work
- Where to Submit: Research literary magazines or contests that fit your genre. Try:
- The Submission Grinder (tracks markets).
- Poets & Writers Literary Magazines Database.
- Self-Publishing: Platforms like Medium, Wattpad, or Substack let you share for free.
Recommended Workflow for You
- Day 1-2: Pre-write (one-sentence summary, character sketches, 5 key scenes).
- Day 3-5: Draft (write 500–1,000 words/day; don’t edit yet).
- Day 6: Rest (step away).
- Day 7-8: Revise (macro edits first, then line edits).
- Day 9: Polish (title, opening line, proofread).
- Day 10: Share (with a reader or submit).
Bonus: Mindset Tips
- Embrace Imperfection: Your first draft is for you; revisions are for readers.
- Set Small Goals: “Write 300 words today” is less intimidating than “Write a story.”
- Read Like a Writer: Study short stories you admire. Ask: How did the author build tension? End the story?
- Suggestions:
- “The Tell-Tale Heart” by Edgar Allan Poe (unreliable narrator).
- “Hills Like White Elephants” by Ernest Hemingway (subtext in dialogue).
- “The Paper Menagerie” by Ken Liu (emotional depth in few words).
- Suggestions:
Reflections as a Human
These models provided decently well-rounded information that did fit the creative writing topic and would help people new to the idea begin to write their own short story. Some sources were better than others, some were trying to advertise, and others just didn’t load. Placing myself into the shoes of a beginner, I believe this would be helpful. The model that worked best with the assigned topic was Mistrial because it formatted the information well, gave sources assigned to each step (even if majority of them didn’t work), and it provided a daily workflow.


